Benchmark Overview

A Benchmark Analysis is meant to answer a practical question:

what does fair reserve fund planning look like?

This page explains the idea in plain language. It is here to help readers understand what the Reserve Sense Benchmark Method is trying to do and why it matters.

What a reserve fund study does

A reserve fund study is a long-term budgeting and planning tool. It looks at the major repair, renewal, refurbishment, and replacement projects a property is expected to face that are not easily accounted for in the operating fund. It then estimates when those projects may occur and how much they might cost, and shows how the reserve fund can prepare for them over time.

The study is meant to support planning and decision-making, including the setting of reserve fund contributions in the annual budget.

What the Benchmark Analysis asks

Within a reserve fund study, the Benchmark Analysis asks two connected questions:

  1. How much money should already be in the reserve fund?
  2. If the reserve fund were at that fair level, how much should the property contribute this year?

By fair we mean two things: every year of a component's life carries the same share of its replacement cost in purchasing-power (CPI-adjusted) terms, and the fund is credited with the interest it earns along the way.

Both Benchmark balances and contributions depend on long-term interest and inflation rates.

Why interest and inflation matter

A Benchmark Analysis spreads a future cost across a component's lifespan. But it cannot simply divide that cost by the number of years involved: it needs to assign a fair share of the cost to each year of ownership. That means the model has to account for how money changes over time.

A reserve fund typically earns interest. If the model ignores that investment income, it will overstate how much owners need to contribute directly.

Money also loses value over time: this is known as inflation. Because of inflation, paying $1,000 today generally means giving up more real buying power than paying $1,000 ten years from now. The dollar amount is the same, but the economic burden is different.

The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method accounts for both effects. It uses interest and CPI inflation together so that Benchmark balances and contributions are measured consistently over time, rather than treating all dollars as though they have the same value in every year.

The Traditional Method

Most reserve fund studies calculate the Benchmark with the same long-standing set of formulas. On these pages we call that the Traditional Method. Its balance target assumes that interest, general inflation, and construction cost increases are all the same, which they rarely are. Its contribution is a flat amount that doesn't keep the fund on that balance target.

What Reserve Sense changes

The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method does not change the goal of Benchmark funding. It still aims to find the reserve fund balance that would be fairly funded under the study's assumptions, with costs spread evenly over time.

What changes is the calculation. Our method uses each of those three rates as the study actually estimates them, and its balance and contribution are built to agree with each other.

The results differ. On the single-component example on the next pages, the two balances are about 8% apart ($1,654 vs $1,519), and the gap is larger for components with longer lifespans. In the reports we have compared, the Traditional Method's first-year contribution typically came out 20–45% higher than ours.

Where to go next