Traditional Method: A Simple Check

The Traditional Method can look reasonable at first glance. It produces a neat schedule, a level annual contribution, and a target number for each year.

But even a very simple example raises some basic questions. Let's isolate one component and see what the formulas are doing.

A simple Traditional Method schedule

Here is the same fitness equipment example used elsewhere in these pages: a current replacement cost of $7,594, construction inflation of 3.5% (so $10,000 at replacement), an effective age of 2 years, a lifespan of 10 years, and interest at 2.9%.

In this example, the Traditional Method maps out a cash flow like this:

Year 2
Opening Balance$589
Interest$17
ARFA$913
Expenditure$0
Closing Balance$1,519
CRFR$1,519

Values in the tables are rounded to the nearest dollar.

At first glance, this looks tidy. The fund grows, the closing balance matches CRFR, the schedule points toward $10,000 by Year 10, and the method appears to work.

But what happened in Year 1?

The Traditional Method says nothing about Year 1. We have filled it in with the only opening balance that gets Year 2 to its CRFR ($589 in the fund) so that we can ask: if $1,519 is where the fund is supposed to be, what got it here? If ARFA is supposed to be the level annual contribution, why does the model appear to begin Year 2 with less than $913? Did the schedule start by under-contributing in Year 1? If not, what exactly is this balance supposed to represent?

A longer timeframe

To explore that, let's expand our timeframe. How does this funding play out over the course of the component's lifespan? ARFA is set at $913 for each year, so we run that cash flow forward as follows:

Year 1Year 2Year 3Year 4Year 5Year 6Year 7Year 8Year 9Year 10
Opening Balance$0$589$1,519$2,476$3,461$4,474$5,517$6,590$7,695$8,831
Interest$0$17$44$72$100$130$160$191$223$256
ARFA?$913$913$913$913$913$913$913$913$913
Expenditure$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0$0($10,000)
Closing Balance$589$1,519$2,476$3,461$4,474$5,517$6,590$7,695$8,831$0
CRFR$734$1,519$2,358$3,254$4,210$5,229$6,314$7,468$8,696$10,000

Now we have even more questions.

What is CRFR supposed to mean?

Why does CRFR only match the closing balance in Year 2?

Also, in Year 10, the Closing Balance is $0 while CRFR is $10,000. Does that mean the replacement year target is shown as $10,000 even though the reserve fund is expected to end the year at $0 after the expenditure?

Why doesn't ARFA increase over time?

The schedule uses interest and inflated future costs, but the recommended ARFA stays level in nominal dollars: $913 per year, every year.

If time value of money matters, why does the contribution not increase over time?

When do funds become available?

At the start of Year 10, the fund opens with only $8,831. Does this assume the funds only become available at the very end of the fiscal year?

An updated study

Now suppose three years pass and we update the study in Year 5.

Nothing fundamental has changed in the example. It is the same component with the same rates and the same replacement year. The only change is that the Effective Age has moved from 2 to 5.

When the Traditional Method is rerun at Effective Age 5, it gives this:

Year 5Year 6Year 7Year 8Year 9Year 10
Opening Balance$3,148$4,210$5,303$6,427$7,584$8,775
Interest$91$122$154$186$220$254
ARFA$971$971$971$971$971$971
Expenditure$0$0$0$0$0($10,000)
Closing Balance$4,210$5,303$6,427$7,584$8,775$0
CRFR$4,210$5,229$6,314$7,468$8,696$10,000

The CRFR didn't change, but everything else did.

Why did the funding path change?

Back in the original schedule, Year 5 looked different:

Original scheduleUpdated in Year 5
Year 5 CRFR$4,210$4,210
Year 5 Closing Balance$4,474$4,210
ARFA going forward$913$971

The target stayed the same, but the path to get there changed.

If $913 was the right annual contribution when the study began, why does it become $971 when we simply move forward to Year 5?

If the original schedule was reliable, why does following it leave the fund above the Year 5 CRFR target, while the updated study calls for an even higher ARFA going forward?

If the fund was on track before, what changed besides time passing?

The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method doesn't have this problem. With the same assumptions, re-running the study in Year 5 gives the same Year 5 figures the original study did.

What this example shows

This example is not a full proof, but it shows why the Traditional Method deserves closer review.

A reserve funding method should behave like one coherent year-by-year model. If we follow its recommendation and later update the study, the method should still make sense on its own terms.