FAQ

This page answers a few common questions that come up after reading the other pages.

It is not a full walkthrough or technical reference. For that, see Walkthrough, Formula Reference, and Modeling Assumptions.

Why calculate annually instead of monthly?

Reserve fund studies are built as annual planning models.

Costs are forecast by fiscal year, contributions are set through annual budgets, and reserve fund cash flows do not usually follow a perfectly smooth monthly pattern in practice. A monthly model could be built, but in most reserve fund studies it would add complexity and assumptions without clearly producing a more reliable result.

The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method therefore uses one consistent annual model.

The Traditional Method also computes its values on an annual basis. The real issue is not annual versus monthly. The real issue is whether the annual model uses coherent timing assumptions and is applied consistently.

Why do cash flows use different timing?

The Benchmark and the cash flow schedules serve different purposes.

The Benchmark is an idealized, point-in-time model. It uses one fixed set of timing assumptions so that Benchmark Balances and Benchmark Contributions have a clear meaning. It calculates each component separately. In that model, expenditures are applied first, interest is earned during the year, and contributions are added at the end of the year. That makes the Benchmark conservative and internally consistent.

A cash flow schedule is different. It is a practical planning tool for a pooled reserve fund. In real life, money moves continuously throughout the year, components can effectively borrow from the shared fund balance, and expenditures do not occur in a perfectly isolated vacuum. For that reason, cash flow schedules are commonly presented using the standard reporting convention that treats that year’s income as available within the same year.

In that sense, the Benchmark timing rules are stricter and more conservative, while the cash flow schedules are a little more flexible and forgiving as practical planning tools.

Does the Reserve Sense Benchmark Method have anything like Reserve Requirements?

Not as a separate shortcut formula.

In the Traditional Method, future-year Reserve Requirements are commonly carried forward from the report-year formulas through a simple formula.

That shortcut is convenient, but it only holds if ARFA never changes. Each component’s Benchmark values change over time, especially during replacement years. The RR formula assumes that ARFA does not change over time, so it cannot track those changes properly.

The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method does not use that kind of shortcut. Instead, it recalculates the Benchmark directly for each fiscal year being modeled, using the component’s updated age, remaining life, projected replacement cost, and the rates used in the study.

For each year, the sum of each component’s values produces that year’s:

  • Benchmark Opening Balance
  • Benchmark Contribution
  • Benchmark Closing Balance

Those values are calculated from that year’s component state and that year’s assumptions. They are not created by simply rolling one year’s result forward.

Isn't this basically the same thing as CRFR and ARFA?

Same goal, same family of formulas. With interest, CPI, and construction inflation all equal, the traditional balance and the Benchmark Opening Balance are identical; CRFR is the special case.

With the rates studies actually use, they differ. The traditional contribution has come out higher than the Benchmark Contribution in every report we have compared: typically 20–45% higher in the first year, more for components with long lifespans or where construction inflation runs well ahead of interest. The traditional balance target can sit above or below the Benchmark Opening Balance, depending on whether interest or construction inflation is the higher rate. Over a 30-year plan the contribution schedules cross (the traditional contribution stays flat while the Benchmark Contribution grows over time, typically overtaking it within about ten years) and the balances pull apart.

The point is not the size of the gap. It is that the traditional target and the traditional contribution rule do not agree with each other. How Big Is the Difference? shows how the gap grows with a component's lifespan.

Who else uses this? Is it sanctioned by a standard?

No standards body has adopted or rejected it. The mathematics is not new. The Benchmark formulas are built on the growing annuity: a series of payments that rise at a constant rate and earn interest. That result follows from summing a geometric series, and actuaries have worked with it since the nineteenth century (see Where this math comes from).

The method itself has been used in published depreciation reports and reserve fund studies across Canada since 2013, and it is the method in every Reserve Sense report.

Is it proprietary? Can I use it in my own reports?

No, and yes. The method is published here as an open specification. Anyone may implement it in their own spreadsheets, software, or reports; we ask that it be cited as the Reserve Sense Benchmark Method with the version number shown on the Overview.

Why not keep using the Traditional Method if it is familiar and seems "close enough"?

Because "close enough" depends on the rates. When interest, CPI, and construction inflation are close together, the traditional balance target lands close to the Benchmark Opening Balance, because that is the special case it comes from. The contributions differ even then: ARFA is a flat amount, while the Benchmark Contribution grows with CPI. When the rates differ, as they do in most studies, the balance gap can go either way: CRFR may sit above or below the Benchmark Opening Balance depending on the component's age, its lifespan, and the rates used, so no simple adjustment makes up for it.

The gaps are not small. In the reports we have compared, the traditional first-year contribution came out 20–45% higher than the Benchmark Contribution, and the balance target was anywhere from 22% below the Benchmark Opening Balance to 14% above it, depending on the rates the study used.

The gap also grows over a study period. Later-year RR values are usually carried forward with a flat ARFA, so the projected funding path moves further from the Benchmark each year, enough to change real budgeting decisions.

The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method keeps the goal, and the familiar balance target as a special case, and calculates the general case directly, so the balances and contributions mean the same thing from year to year.

Do I need to build these formulas manually?

No.

The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method is a published method, so it can be implemented in any suitable tool. But you do not need to build and maintain the formulas yourself.

Reserve Sense software applies the Reserve Sense Benchmark Method directly and handles the Benchmark calculations automatically. It recalculates each fiscal year’s values and handles staged replacements, one-time expenditures, funding model calculations, and annual rate updates, so you can focus on inspection, analysis, and advice rather than maintaining spreadsheet formulas.