This page gives the core formulas used in the Reserve Sense Benchmark Method.
It is a reference page, not a step-by-step explanation. For that, see the Walkthrough.
Timing assumptions
For the timing rules behind these formulas, see Modeling Assumptions. These formulas assume that:
- expenditures are applied at the start of the year
- interest is
j × (BOB − E), credited at year-end - the year's contribution is added at year-end and earns no interest in the year it is made
Variables
CRC = Current Replacement Cost
FRC = Future Replacement Cost
LS = Lifespan
EA = Effective Age
RL = Remaining Life
i = Long-term construction cost inflation rate
g = Long-term CPI inflation rate
j = Long-term interest rate
BAC = Benchmark Annual Contribution for the fiscal year being modeled
BOB = Benchmark Opening Balance at the start of the fiscal year
BCB = Benchmark Closing Balance at the end of the fiscal year
E = Expenditure for the component during the fiscal year
Remaining Life
Remaining Life is the portion of the lifespan that has not yet been used up.
For a newly installed component, EA = 0. For that component, RL = LS.
Future Replacement Cost
The Future Replacement Cost is the estimated cost of the component in the year of its next expected replacement.
This formula applies construction cost inflation over the component's remaining life.
Benchmark Contribution
The Benchmark Contribution is the contribution for the relevant fiscal year that is level in CPI-adjusted terms over the component's life and, with interest at j, accumulates exactly to FRC by the replacement year.
When j ≠ g
A separate form is needed when j = g because the standard expressions otherwise collapse into a zero denominator.
When j = g
This is the annual contribution for a given year, not necessarily the first year's contribution for a brand-new component.
Benchmark Opening Balance
The Benchmark Opening Balance is the fair amount that should be in the reserve fund for a component at the start of the relevant fiscal year.
When j ≠ g
When j = g
Replacement years and components past their lifespan
Effective Age is a whole number of years. When RL = 0 the component is in its replacement year: BOB = FRC, the expenditure is applied at the start of the year, and for a repeating component a new cycle begins at EA = 0 with its own BAC (see Modeling Assumptions).
A component whose Effective Age exceeds its Lifespan is treated as already in a later cycle. Its age within the current cycle is what remains after subtracting the whole lifespans it has completed: with EA = 25 and LS = 10, the component is treated as 5 years into its third cycle, with its next replacement 5 years away. When EA is an exact multiple of LS, the component is in a replacement year. The method does not add a catch-up replacement on its own. To model an overdue replacement in the current year, set EA = LS.
Benchmark Closing Balance
The Benchmark Closing Balance is the fair amount that should be in the reserve fund for this component at the end of the relevant fiscal year.
When j ≠ g
When j = g
Check: with FRC = $10,000, LS = 10, EA = 2, j = 2.9% and g = 1.9%, these formulas give BAC = $839, BOB = $1,654 and BCB = $2,540: the Year 2 figures in the Walkthrough.
Interest relationship
If a component has an expenditure during the fiscal year, and that expenditure is written as E, then:
and:
If there is no expenditure during the year, then E = 0.
Fund-level totals
The Benchmark is calculated separately for each component. The total reserve fund Benchmark for a given year is then found by summing the component results for that same year.
Here, k indexes the components in the study, n is the total number of components, and t is the year being modeled.
For year :
Each component has its own lifespan, effective age, inflation path, and replacement timing. The method therefore does not calculate one blended formula for the reserve fund as a whole.
Instead, Benchmark values are calculated separately for each component in each year of the study, and fund-level totals are found by summing component values from that same year.
Where this math comes from
The Reserve Sense Benchmark Method does not use new mathematics. The Benchmark Contribution and Benchmark Balance formulas are the accumulated value of an annuity whose payments grow at a constant rate, solved for the first payment that reaches a known target. This annuity appears in the standard actuarial and finance texts:
- Kellison, The Theory of Interest, 3rd ed. (McGraw-Hill, 2009), §4.7, "Payments varying in geometric progression"
- Broverman, Mathematics of Investment and Credit, 7th ed. (ACTEX Learning, 2017), §2.3.1, "Annuities whose payments form a geometric progression"
- Vaaler, Harper, and Daniel, Mathematical Interest Theory, 3rd ed. (AMS/MAA, 2019), §3.8, "Annuities with payments in geometric progression"
- Society of Actuaries, Exam FM syllabus, "Geometric progression, finite term and perpetuity"
In those texts, the annuity is written as a present value with the first payment given. The Benchmark formulas use the same annuity's accumulated value and solve for the first payment, so they will not appear in the books in exactly this form.
In corporate finance it is called the growing annuity; in engineering economics, the geometric gradient series. The case j = g is the limiting form given in those texts.
What Reserve Sense adds is the application: three separate rates (construction inflation i for the replacement cost, CPI g for contribution growth, and interest j for accumulation), a per-component Benchmark Opening Balance, Benchmark Contribution, and Benchmark Closing Balance for every year of the study, and one timing convention that ties them together.
With all three rates set equal, the Benchmark Opening Balance reduces to:
This is the Current Reserve Fund Requirement (CRFR) of the Traditional Method. The traditional benchmark is the special case of this one in which interest and inflation are assumed to cancel.
Where to go next
This page shows only the formulas.
- Go to Benchmark Overview to understand what a Benchmark Analysis is.
- Go to Walkthrough to see the method step by step.
- Go to Modeling Assumptions for the timing rules behind the method.
- Go to Traditional Method: A Simple Check to follow one component and see where the commonly used Traditional Method breaks down.